A Non-Review of the Willows Inn, Lummi Isl., WA: Locavore or Loco-what?

While I do not do restaurant reviews or “serious” essays on IslandEAT, I have been thinking about a recent fine-dining “locavore” experience at the Willows Inn, Lummi Island, Washington.  It was one of New York Times10 Restaurants Worth a Plane Ride.  This is a lofty honour for a restaurant on an obscure island of 800 year-round residents off Bellingham, WA.

If you are not familiar with the term – in its most simplistic definition  – “locavore” refers to a person who focuses on local, in-season foods, in large part or exclusively.  The philosophy behind this “locavorean” ideal is that local foods:

  1.  Taste better, as they have not traveled tremendous distances.
  2. Work better together, as they are from the same area/region.
  3. Feature high nutritional value: they are fresh, seasonal, and often organic.
  4. Benefit the environment more, due to less packaging and transportation.
  5. Create less waste (see #4) and are to satisfy – but not stuff.
  6. Support local economies, small farmers, and independent growers.
  7. Represent how humans – or other animals – are meant to eat.

The above definition is my explanation and understanding of what constitutes a “locavorean” approach to eating.  It is one that makes sense to me as well as one I try to follow, to a large extent.  For me, I cannot find – or “source” – locally produced citrus, avocados, olive oil, cocoa/chocolate, vanilla beans, coffee, and tea (black, green, or white, that is, as opposed to herbal teas or tisanes).  Hence, I am not a hard-line “locavore”, as I have not stopped consuming these staples – at least staples in my kitchen.

Salmon comes from the Gulf Islands, though the lemon does not...

However, I eat only blackberries I have picked, as they are free and abundant in the Gulf Islands; buy eggs – all free-range/grain-fed/organic – just a 20-minute walk up the road; and have harvested nettles for cooking.   It is rare that I have any fish or shell fish from outside the seafood-rich waters of British Columbia, even some of which comes from right off this island.  (Here are some of my favourite recipes for maple-ginger-soy salmonsalmon chowderhalibut with lime-ginger-cayennehalibut cheeks, and scallops in brown butter with hazelnuts.)  Last week, I had eaten lamb raised on a farm on the other side of the bay, which I can see right from our house.  So that is pretty good, as far as “locavores” go.  I am privileged to live in a place where all this is possible.

For the “non-review”, keep reading…

When the New York Times named Willows Inn one of the Top 10 Restaurants Worth a Plane Trip for 2011, I thought it would be fun to check out this place – besides, it would give me another island to add to my list….so off we went on my recent birthday.  Here is the profile of 24-year-old chef-wunderkind, Blaine Wetzel, from the Willows Inn’s site.  Before coming to the Willows Inn last year, Blaine had worked for René Redzepi at Copenhagen’s Noma, the top restaurant in the world, according to some.

The five-course prix fixe chef’s tasting menu is $70 (though it will rise to $85 in high-season – and I bet it will go up from there, due to the demand).  It is a very good value, as these things go.  All the food was creative, well-prepared, and nicely presented on pottery, produced, one assumes, by a local artisan.  To understand their approach better, here is Chef Blaine ‘splainin’ it all to you via video: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WomwVG-1nQU

After four amuse-bouches during the course of one hour, the five courses arrived, with plenty, if not too much time, in between.  Then there was an after-dessert treat.  It turned into a three-and-a-half hour dining experience.  This is fine for those who were staying at the Inn, but for those who had to drive back to Seattle or Vancouver, with an hourly ferry schedule, it was a bit drawn-out.

However, I do have some issues around this kind of meal philosophically in the “locavorean context” (how very academic of me).   The two primary issues for me were the origins of some drinks and the volume of the meal.

If you are not familiar with the British Columbia/Pacific Northwest wine super-region, you might not know that some of the best North American wines – or anywhere – come from this area.  So why, I must ask, would the Willows Inn serve Prosecco, which comes from Italy, to guests at the beginning of the meal?  There are fine sparkling wines from B.C., Washington, and Oregon. Of the optional wine pairings, the majority were not from the region, nor were most of the liquors served during the cocktail hour.  While such local wines might cost more (and the Prosecco was complimentary), it is an odd choice for a restaurant which espouses the “locavore” approach.

Similarly, the restaurant offered black-green-white teas and coffee.  While all the food may be local, coffee and tea certainly are not.  This is not the same issue as the wine, but it is a philosophical point which contradicts the emphasis on the food.  To their credit, however, there was an optional juice pairing of house-made juices to accompany the meal; these were all very local.

The other point is excess.  The bread offered was wonderful, but the over-zealous and well-trained staff removed the bread basket when it had a piece or two left, only to be replaced by more, without asking.  We had a cocktail, the gratis Prosecco, and a glass of wine with one of the five courses, and this seemed to be more than enough.  I can only imagine how absolutely drunk  those who had the five different wine pairing must have been, after the Prosecco (and possibly a cocktail or two before the meal). This strikes me as contradictory to the locavore philosophy or “waste not, want not”.

Five courses, combined with the four amuse-bouches, endless bread, and a post-dessert sweet of a caramel with flax-seed, with drinks, are quite a bit for one meal.  In fact, I would hazard to guess that it was simply far too much food for most adults, especially ending so late in the evening.  This would contradict the “locavore” approach to healthful, adequate yet moderate consumption.

My last point is that I had not intended to do a restaurant review.  I appreciate the writing of qualified, professional food critics as well as using Zagat guides (I contributed to past Vancouver and Chicago editions).  While I have some familiarity with fine-dining and have eaten at some of the world’s best restaurants in places like Paris, New York, Chicago, Seattle, and Vancouver, I am not a food critic.

I did not take photos, so the ones here are mine of the Gulf Islands scenery, which is not unlike the area around Lummi Island, further south of my island.  I must mention observing a small woman, seated at the most prominent table at the Willows Inn, who used flash photography to capture every item she ate…not to mention that I noticed she been enjoying the wine-pairings, so much so that she was “all over” her dining companion by evening’s end.

Home - at last - after eating too much "locavore" cuisine....

This is an odd piece to write, as I still think it was an exceptional meal. Nonetheless, I did not feel particularly well afterwards due to the quantities and the next day felt exhausted.  Perhaps I am not meant to have tasting menus these days (Anthony Bourdain has written about his dislike of them, so it is not just me…), but I do wonder about the whole “locavore” approach and how that translates – or not – into fine dining.

20 responses to “A Non-Review of the Willows Inn, Lummi Isl., WA: Locavore or Loco-what?

  1. Hopefully when I return home I will be able to be more of a locavore than what I am here in Mauritius.
    🙂 Mandy

  2. THAT SUNSET. That scenery! Wow. Just wow.

    Okay, now that I’ve gotten past my slack-jawed reaction to your photos—wonderful observations, Dan. “Locavore” is such a buzzword right now, and it’s in every conscious consumer’s best interest to read a thoughtful critique of those who are using it. Food for thought abounds here!

    • Thanks very much for the compliments, Maddie. I was trying to figure out a why to use up some other shots from on the island and right around, and they seem to fit well with the “locavore” theme.

      I hope it turns out to be more than a food fad or short-lived trend, but I worry that hard-liners in the movement might turn-off the more mainstream, who want to consume sustainable (another “buzz” word) locally-produced food due to strict ideology. Hey, that is a bit heavy as wishes go, no?


  3. love this non-review! Your reflections on your meal are thoughtful and bang on…but I agree with you about the whole blogger as restaurant critic…and am not comfortable doing it either. And don`t even get me started on flash photography at the table!

    It sounds overall, though, like an amazing meal — and worth the trip — especially with the local scenery…Theresa

    • Hi, Theresa. I appreciate your feedback on the issues and confirmation that we think alike! Maybe it’s the island mentality take hold of both of us….



  4. I have very fond memories of Lummi when I travelled there with my husband about ten years ago. We especially came to appreciate the ferry wait as locals hopped out of their cars and visited each other while waiting for the ferry to appear. Your photos make me wish I could return there soon.

    • Thanks, Geni. I find it amusing that you actually visited Lummi, which is quite far from L.A., both geographically and metaphorically….

      I should admit that the photos are in the Canadian Gulf Islands, rather than the American San Juan Islands. However, they do look very similar, despite the national separation.


  5. Hey Dan,
    Great post! Though folks in Southern Cali, try to eat ‘locally’, I don’t hear the word locavore ever used here, so thrilled to learn something new. Taking a boat ride to a fancy rest sounds like a grand of an evening!!

    • Hi, Jenny. How nice of you to compliment me! I am used to ferry rides to all sorts of restaurants – fancy and otherwise – so I don’t really give it a second thought anymore. But it does make it fun and different for most people.



  6. Interesting, Dan. I remember you telling me that you went here for your birthday and it made me want to go too, but you make some excellent points about its flaws as well.

    This was a great post, though. You should write more non-reviews =)

    Jax x

    PS: Hi! I know I haven’t been around much lately, things are keraaazy over my side of the pond!

    • Thanks, Jax. I appreciate your feedback, and I thought of this more on an essay about “locavorism” than a review. Now that the wedding hub-bub is over, will your keraaaziness slow down?


  7. Great points you brought up that are not often addressed in reviews but should be. I especially agree with the comments on excess, and have felt the same way about bread basket situation. You have me curious about the restaurant, and as its near Bellingham, and conveniently we have family there, I may need to check it out for myself, Do they only offer the tasting menu, or can you order a la carte?

    • Thanks, Louann, for your nice comments. The restaurant does tasting menus exclusively these days – one of the financial requirements, I imagine, for a small dining room in a remote location. It is worth trying, however.


  8. Great review – especially since i am in the area 🙂 I still have not been to Lummi Island and need to go. I have been in WA for 8 years and i still have a few places to visit 🙂 In two weeks i am going to the Oregon coast Cannon Beach for the first time, another one on the list is Tofino, BC.

  9. Hope everything is well with you Dan, and I am looking forward to your next post.

  10. how lucky to have such a salmon !!!pierre

  11. You on a vacation? Where did you go?

  12. 11302 355732Couldn?t be developed any much better. Reading this post reminds me of my old room mate! He always kept talking about this. I will forward this report to him. Pretty certain he will possess a great read. Thanks for sharing! 993872

  13. 369825 340702Intersting post and internet site. Very good that Google listed so i was able to get here. This internet site will go no in my bookmarks from now. 409309

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s